After being wowed by the guys this week, the girls were just so-so. I watched David Cook’s and Jason Castro’s performances multiple times. See them both below. I love Brooke and thought she did the best last night, but I probably won’t re-view it.
Here’s my personal ranking of how the Idols did this week:
Top 3 Guys:
- Jason Castro
- David Cook
- David Archuleta
Bottom 3 Guys:
- Luke Menard
- Danny Noriega
- David Hernandez
Top 2 Girls:
- Brooke White
- Amanda Overmyer
Bottom 2 Girls:
- Kady Malloy (I *loved* her the first week, since then, not)
- Kristy Lee Cook
I thought David Cook’s song was the best this week. I just loved it. Love, love, loved it. That being said. I *do* love Jason Castro as well. I’d hate to see him leave.
I wasn’t impressed with any of the girls really. Except for Brooke. Brooke was awesome
Can I just say how much I’m loving Jason one more time?
I so hope he ends up with a cd ’cause I could listen to it all day!
David Cook took me by surprise this week. I haven’t been a fan, but his performance was amazing. But David Archuleta and Jason Castro are *still* my favorite.
The girls are just so so. The only one that I think has a chance is either Brooke or Ramiele Malubay, though I don’t really like Ramiele. I do like Asia’h, though.
I think one of the guys is going to take it this year.
Well, I don’t watch Idol but I’m sure enjoying the clips. So, thank you for that. I loved the David Cook version of “Hello”. Love it, love it.
YAY! I am so excited to find some people who love Jason as much as I do!