Masterpiece
*****
Excellent
**** 1/2
Very good
****
Good
**** 1/2
Just okay
***
Not for me
**
Definitely not for me
*

Uncool to be a reader

“We just don’t like to read as much as you do, Mom.”

I’ve heard this several times (even recently) from both of my sons, particularly my youngest.  However, I know differently, and I’m thankful this statement isn’t true.

Both of my sons blow away everyone at school on their AR points — it’s not even close.  They are more well-read than I was at their age.  They know more about history.  They know more about science.  Over the years they have read and/or listened to (and I know I’ll miss some important ones):

  • the complete Chronicles of Narnia
  • at least 5 or 6 Redwall titles
  • the complete Harry Potter series
  • the complete Chronicles of Prydain
  • the complete Artemis Fowl series
  • the complete Dark Is Rising series
  • the Bartimaeus trilogy
  • the Eragon trilogy
  • the Inkheart trilogy
  • several Newberys (more than I have read)
  • all of The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit (2 more than their mother)
  • and numerous other titles

So, I’ve often wondered, ‘Why do they say they’re not readers?’  The only reason I can come up with is that it’s ‘uncool’ nowadays to be a reader — especially for boys.  They have plenty of other hobbies.  One of my sons is into sports and both of them enjoy video games.  We’re into sci-fi tv and movies as a family.  But, they don’t want to admit that they’re readers.  No matter.  I know the truth, and I consider reading to be one of the best values we’ve instilled into our children.  As far as I know, there is no magical formula to turn kids into readers.  And though it won’t be practical for most, the following is what we did to help that goal along.

When we made the decision to homeschool, I also made the decision to try to turn my sons onto reading.  They had always enjoyed my husband or I reading to them, but they hadn’t really picked up the habit on their own.  So, I ‘encouraged’ (forced) them to read for 1.5 hours per day.  Sound unreasonable?  Not really.  One half hour was for reading fiction, another half hour for history written in a fictional style (thank you H.A. Guerber and Christine Miller), and another half hour was for reading about science (thank you Jeannie Fulbright).  It wasn’t all at once, unless they preferred it, and oftentimes they would extend the time of one or all sessions by their own choosing.

We don’t homeschool anymore (though I am wistful of those precious days), and my kids go to public school now, but despite what they say, they ARE readers, even if it’s uncool to admit it.  And I’m thankful.  So thankful.

Property by Valerie Martin

propertyWinner of the 2003 Orange Prize, Property by Valerie Martin is an extremely readable story set in the South and is, obviously, about slavery and what it means to be free.

Manon is the wife of a cruel slaveowner and is miserable in her marriage.  She idealizes her father, who was kind (relatively speaking) to his slaves, and hates her husband, but really, she is not that kind to her slaves herself.  Manon is not a likable character at all, though we do feel a little sympathetic toward her situation.  Her attitudes toward slavery were probably typical of the time — in other words, deplorable.

It is ironic that Manon really is ‘property’ to her husband as well.  I believe that is the thrust of the novel.  There is a parallel story between her and her slave Sarah.  Both desperately want freedom, but Manon cannot understand why Sarah won’t accept her position as slave.  There is a certain scene between Manon and Sarah that I *did not* care for, but it illustrated Manon’s attitudes perfectly.  She was enforcing her ‘ownership’ of Sarah just as her husband did.

I thought the story was leading up to a certain conclusion in the end, but it didn’t happen, and the book ends a bit abruptly.  Though I wanted more, the book definitely is thought-provoking.  It is a quick read — I read it in a single day, and I do recommend it if you’re interested in the time period or Orange Prize winners.

Valerie Martin is a native of New Orleans so I am also counting this for the Southern Reading Challenge.

2002, 192 pp.

stars4.gif

Orange July

orangejuly2A group of us are participating in Orange July, and I haven’t posted my intention to participate yet — after we’re almost halfway through the month!  I have been reading winners and shortlist and longlist titles, which all qualify.

Books so far:

  1. How I Live Now by Meg Rosoff (2005 new writers’ shortlist)
  2. Intuition by Allegra Goodman (2009 longlist)
  3. Property by Valerie Martin (2003 winner)
Blog Widget by LinkWithin