Masterpiece
*****
Excellent
**** 1/2
Very good
****
Good
**** 1/2
Just okay
***
Not for me
**
Definitely not for me
*

The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo

The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo
by Stieg Larsson

2008, 465 pp.
stars3h.gif

The original Swedish title of this book means Men Who Hated Women, and that title is an excellent forewarning about what the book is about.  If you like gritty crime novels or shows like CSI, you’ll probably love the book.   My eyes and stomach prefer much milder fare, but I’ll still probably read the second installment, The Girl Who Played with Fire, when it comes out next year.

The girl who has the dragon tattoo is Lisbeth Salander, a girl in her mid-twenties who is a PI and can find out just about everything about anyone.  I liked her.  A lot.   Her character was fascinating and Larsson ends the book in such a way that leaves you wanting to hear more of her story and background.

Mikael Blomqvist is a journalist who has just lost a court case for libel, which then puts his reputation and his magazine Millennium at risk.  He decides to temporarily leave the paper in the hands of his partner to save face.  Enter Henrik Vanger.  Vanger is the former CEO of his family business, the Vanger Corporation.  He hires Blomqvist to write a family history of the Vangers as a pretext to dig into the disappearance of his niece, Harriet Vanger.  The case has been cold for decades and though Mikael believes he won’t be able to find any new evidence, he accepts.  This is where the book really grabbed me and kept me reading until 1 am to learn the outcome.

The book really has three storylines to it, the Harriet Vanger story is in the middle, with Lisbeth Salander’s story on the outside of that, and with Mikael Blomqvist’s story on the very outer edges.  Consequently, the climax occurs with quite a few pages still left in the book.  So at first it felt like the book should be over, but then after awhile I was able to get into the secondary and tertiary stories as well.

As I stated in the beginning, it really is about men who hate women, so if you read it be prepared for what that involves.  I didn’t care for the more graphic scenes in the book, but I do know that not everyone is as sensitive to that as I am.  And I do want to find out more about the girl with the dragon tattoo when The Girl Who Played with Fire comes out next year.

The Story of a Marriage

The Story of a Marriage
by Andrew Sean Greer

2008, 195 pp.
stars1.gif

It seems this story has polarized readers. Some love it, while others intensely dislike the book. I fall into the latter camp. I thought I was really going to like it initially, but then the story went way over the top into unbelievability for me. I found myself disliking it more and more as the pages progressed. It’s really almost impossible to speak about the issues I had with the book without giving away some huge spoilers, but I will give you a taste of what it’s about.

Holland and Pearlie Cook are childhood sweethearts with a son and a dog that doesn’t bark. Everything is going along fine until one day Buzz, a man from Holland’s past, shows up at the door and changes everything.  Set in the 50′s and San Francisco.

Those who loved it:

Those who didn’t:

Those who were mixed:

If you’d like me to add your review, just let me know in the comments!

The Secret Scripture

The Secret Scripture
by Sebastian Barry

2008, 300 pp.
Booker Prize Shortlist
Rating: stars4h.gif

What can I tell you further? I once lived among humankind, and found them in their generality to be cruel and cold, and yet could mention the names of three or four that were like angels.

I’d be happy if this book won the Booker Prize.  Yeah, I would, and I haven’t read any of the other contenders yet!  Sebastian Barry is a magnificent writer, and I will definitely be reading more of his work.

Roseanne McNulty is almost 100 years old, and Dr. Grene is the psychiatrist attending her at Roscommon Mental Hospital.  The story slowly unfolds by giving alternating accounts of Roseanne and Dr. Grene.  As he seeks to understand her and her tragic past, he must also deal with some tragedy of his own.  As everyone knows, ‘grief lasts two years.’

With Ireland as a backdrop and themes of religion, mental illness, and family loyalty and betrayal, The Secret Scripture is superbly crafted and is definitely worthy of the Booker Prize.

The Bible Salesman by Clyde Edgerton

biblesalesman.JPGI was first introduced to Clyde Edgerton when I read and enjoyed Walking Across Egypt (4 stars) last year, so I was really looking forward to reading this book.  Henry Dampier is a young man determined to make his fortune by door-to-door Bible selling; although, truth be told, he gets the Bibles for free.  Still, quite a few customers (especially ladies) do buy his product, but it is not until con man Preston Clearwater invites him to work for the FBI that his income really starts improving.  Henry is quite naive and soon gets caught up in more than he bargained for — in both work and love.

One of the reasons I enjoy Edgerton’s work is that he captures the southern character very well.  I lived 17 years in the south, and I felt like the characters in the novel were very authentic.  I really enjoyed the first half of the book.  The second half, not so much.   The charm and plot of the story broke down a bit, and I ended up a little disappointed in the end.  Still, I’d like to read another book by Edgerton, perhaps for next year’s Southern Reading Challenge.

2008, 238 pp.
Rating: stars3h.gif

Review: Blankets by Craig Thompson

blankets.JPGThere is a lot going on in Craig Thompson’s autobiographical graphic novel Blankets.  With a deeply personal touch, Thompson draws and writes about his childhood and teenage years and their hardships, joys, and discoveries.  Writing about his brother, family, church camps, and first love, Thompson lays it all bare.  He truly had some difficult things to deal with in his childhood that no child should have to face, and we see him struggle with his faith and family relationships as a result.

While I admire the book’s artwork, story, and the author himself, it is difficult for me to write this review as I disagree with (but am mostly sad about) the book’s conclusion.  As I was reading the book, I was hoping for it to end a certain way when in fact it went the 180 degree opposite direction.  Of course, this is the author’s life so he has every right to write about and illustrate how he really feels, but… I was still very sad at the end.  There’s no denying he has a gift for writing and illustration, though, and I would definitely pick up another one of Thompson’s graphic novels in the future.

The picture below is one of the illustrations dealing with the first night that he and his brother finally get their own rooms.   After waiting so long for them after sharing a room for many years, it’s not hard to imagine what happens that first night.  I’ll save that for you to read on your own, though! (This book has mature themes and I wouldn’t recommend it for those under 16 or 17.)

592 pp., 2003
Rating: stars4.gif

blankets2.PNG

Review: The Photograph by Penelope Lively

photograph.JPGAfter his wife Kath’s death, Glyn is going through all her paperwork and finds a folder with ‘DO NOT OPEN: DESTROY’ on it.  Of course he opens it, only to find a picture of his wife holding hands with another man.  Glyn  then sets out to find out about the details of his wife’s life that he never knew about, and he finds out that he really didn’t know his wife all that well.  As he finds out more and more, he needs to enlist Kath’s friends and her sister Elaine to fill in the gaps to the mystery, ‘Who was Kath, really?’

This book is about marriage, friendships, and family relationships.   Who takes precedence over whom and why.  Who really knows the true soul of a person and why.  How does one even go about trying to find out the true self of a loved one?  This book really engaged me because of the intertwined, complex relationships of all the characters and how they related to the ‘mystery’ of who Kath really was.  Recommended.

231 pp., 2003
Rating: stars4.gif