Masterpiece
*****
Excellent
**** 1/2
Very good
****
Good
**** 1/2
Just okay
***
Not for me
**
Definitely not for me
*

Mudbound by Hillary Jordan

Hillary Jordan has written a very good debut novel that speaks on war, racism, marriage, and living off the land. The story is told by various narrators throughout the book. Henry and Laura are a white married couple who move to the Mississippi delta to raise cotton. Henry loves the land, but Laura misses city life and is deeply unhappy.  She also has to live and deal with her racist father-in-law for the first time.

Hap and Florence are a black couple living on Henry’s farm as renters.  Hap is a preacher, while Florence is a midwife who also helps Laura with some of her housework.  Their oldest child Ronsel is in the military and serving in Germany, and when he comes back, he has to adjust back to a way of life that he is no longer accustomed to.  He does find a friend, however, in Jamie, Henry’s younger brother.  But, this doesn’t sit well with Henry and Jamie’s father, and trouble ensues.

This book all too painfully illustrates how much African-Americans have had to go through in this country. It does seem like the tide has changed with the historic election of our first black President, Barack Obama.  I sincerely hope that this event will be the turning point in race relations in the United States.

(All along while reading this book, I was thinking it was going to receive a 4.5 rating, but then at the end something is stated by Jamie that I was deeply offended by, and I changed my rating to a 4.  It didn’t ruin the book for me, but I think a better choice of words should have been uilized to avoid offending some readers.)

2008, 328 pp.
stars4.gif

Goldengrove by Francine Prose


“to a young child”

Margaret, are you grieving
Over Goldengrove unleaving?
Leaves, like the things of man, you
With your fresh thoughts care for, can you?
Ah! as the heart grows older
It will come to such sights colder
By & by, nor spare a sigh
Though worlds of wanwood leafmeal lie;
And yet you will weep & know why.
Now no matter, child, the name:
Sorrow’s springs are the same.
Nor mouth had, no nor mind, expressed
What heart heard of, ghost guessed:
It is the blight man was born for,
It is Margaret you mourn for.

–Gerard Manley Hopkins

Grief is such an individual, totally consuming, and heart-wrenching experience — especially when the death is by a young person or is totally unexpected.  This book explores the grief process very well.  Margaret and Nico are teenage sisters.  While Nico generally seeks out her parent’s approval, Margaret is a little on the wild side.  However, that is not what gets her killed.  Margaret has a heart problem and ends up drowning in the lake near their home.

The story is told from Nico’s point of view, and about her struggle to get through each day, each month, each year.  She worries about her own health and about how her parents are coping with her sister’s death.  She’s concerned for her sister’s boyfriend and how he’s dealing with it.  She even endures those around her who try to make her into parts of Margaret instead of herself.

Finally, the story ends with an adult Nico writing about how she and her family have recovered from their grief over the years.  Although — as anyone knows who has been through it — you never really get over the death of someone close to you.

2008, 288 pp.
stars4.gif

The Pigman by Paul Zindel

I read this title for Banned Books Week and also because I needed a ‘Z’ author.  It’s an older book, written in 1968, so the content may have been a little more shocking back then, but really, I’m as conservative as they come, and I don’t have a problem with it at all.  Yes, there is defiance of authority and alcohol reference, but with what our kids have to deal with in today’s world, this book is very mild in comparison.  It’s actually a very poignant book.

I always like stories that show how strong bonds can be made with those you don’t expect — especially if you don’t have those strong bonds in your own family life.  After John and Lorraine meet 50-ish Mr. Pignati, the three of them start spending more and more time together. At first the teenagers are a little embarassed by Mr. Pignati, who has a childlikeness to him, but soon the threesome are fast friends.  Sadly, it’s the teenagers’ own immaturity that ends up threatening the friendship. Recommended.

(1968, 182 pp.)

stars4.gif

The Borden Tragedy

The Borden Tragedy
by Rick Geary

1997, 80 pp.
Rating: stars4.gif

I only vaguely knew the story of Lizzie Borden, so this little graphic novel was really an engrossing look at this true crime.  Geary’s drawings are great, and he presents cases both for Lizzie Borden’s guilt and for her innocence.  The back of the book also has reproductions of the actual newspaper clippings.  Fascinating story!

This book is part of the Treasury of Victorian Murder series that I will have to look into!

Darkness Visible by William Styron

Darkness Visible
by William Styron

1990, 84 pp.
Rating: stars4.gif

In this short memoir chronicling the author’s own bout with depression, Styron gives us a glimpse of the pain and madness of the disease.  Styron not only provides us with details of his own illness, but also expounds on the suicides and/or depression of other authors.  He also gives guidelines and suggestions for action to those who have a loved one suffering with the disease.

Styron was the author of Sophie’s Choice and the Pulitzer Prize winning The Confessions of Nat Turner. He died in 2006 at the age of 81 from pneumonia.

Review: Blankets by Craig Thompson

blankets.JPGThere is a lot going on in Craig Thompson’s autobiographical graphic novel Blankets.  With a deeply personal touch, Thompson draws and writes about his childhood and teenage years and their hardships, joys, and discoveries.  Writing about his brother, family, church camps, and first love, Thompson lays it all bare.  He truly had some difficult things to deal with in his childhood that no child should have to face, and we see him struggle with his faith and family relationships as a result.

While I admire the book’s artwork, story, and the author himself, it is difficult for me to write this review as I disagree with (but am mostly sad about) the book’s conclusion.  As I was reading the book, I was hoping for it to end a certain way when in fact it went the 180 degree opposite direction.  Of course, this is the author’s life so he has every right to write about and illustrate how he really feels, but… I was still very sad at the end.  There’s no denying he has a gift for writing and illustration, though, and I would definitely pick up another one of Thompson’s graphic novels in the future.

The picture below is one of the illustrations dealing with the first night that he and his brother finally get their own rooms.   After waiting so long for them after sharing a room for many years, it’s not hard to imagine what happens that first night.  I’ll save that for you to read on your own, though! (This book has mature themes and I wouldn’t recommend it for those under 16 or 17.)

592 pp., 2003
Rating: stars4.gif

blankets2.PNG